What Chatgpt Can’t Teach My Writing Students

Artificial Intelligence Software

As a writing instructor, I have been witness to the incredible advancements in AI technology, particularly in the field of natural language processing. One such breakthrough is ChatGPT, a state-of-the-art language model that can generate human-like text. While ChatGPT has its merits and can assist in various areas, there are certain aspects of writing that it simply cannot teach my students. In this article, I will delve into the limitations of ChatGPT and explain why human guidance and creativity are still essential for nurturing strong writing skills.

Limited Contextual Understanding

One of the main limitations of ChatGPT lies in its contextual understanding. While it can generate coherent sentences and even engage in conversations, it lacks the deep comprehension that comes from real-life experiences and human emotions. As a writing instructor, I believe that crafting powerful narratives and evoking empathy in readers require a deep understanding of emotions and personal connections, something that ChatGPT cannot replicate.

Additionally, ChatGPT may struggle with understanding the unique needs and preferences of individual students. Each writer has their own style, voice, and target audience. Providing tailored feedback and guidance based on these individual characteristics is something that can only be done effectively by a human instructor.

Creative Thinking and Originality

While ChatGPT is capable of generating text based on existing patterns and examples, it falls short when it comes to fostering creative thinking and originality in writing. The ability to generate unique ideas, develop engaging plots, and create memorable characters are skills that develop through practice and personal exploration. As an instructor, I encourage my students to think outside the box and embrace their own unique perspectives, a quality that cannot be instilled solely through AI-powered tools like ChatGPT.

Furthermore, writing is not just about stringing words together; it’s about capturing the essence of a thought or idea in a way that resonates with the reader. It requires the ability to engage the reader’s imagination, stir up emotions, and leave a lasting impact. These elements are deeply rooted in the human experience and can’t be fully encapsulated by an AI model.

Ethical and Legal Considerations

While AI technology has made tremendous progress, it is not without its ethical and legal concerns. ChatGPT, like any other AI language model, can inadvertently produce biased or misleading content. It is the responsibility of a human instructor to critically evaluate and reshape the information provided by these models, ensuring that it is accurate, objective, and aligned with ethical standards. Teaching students to think critically and ethically about the information they consume and produce is a crucial aspect of writing instruction that can’t be replaced by AI tools alone.


While ChatGPT and other AI language models have revolutionized the way we interact with technology and process information, they cannot completely replace the role of human guidance and creativity in the realm of writing. The contextual understanding, creative thinking, and ethical considerations that humans bring to the table are invaluable in nurturing the growth of strong writing skills. As a writing instructor, I believe in harnessing the power of AI to assist my students, but I also emphasize the significance of human connection, personal experiences, and critical thinking in developing exceptional writers.