How Do You Know She’s A Witch Monty Python

How To Articles

So, you want to know how to tell if someone is a witch? Well, let me tell you, it’s not as easy as it seems. But fear not, for I am here to guide you through the intricacies of identifying a witch, Monty Python style.

First things first, we must establish a foundation of knowledge. In the classic Monty Python sketch, “How do you know she’s a witch?”, a group of medieval villagers uses various methods to determine if a woman accused of witchcraft is indeed guilty. Now, keep in mind that this sketch is purely comedic and not meant to be taken seriously, but it does offer some hilarious and exaggerated insights into the subject.

The Duck Test

One of the most memorable scenes in the sketch involves the villagers using the “duck test” to identify a witch. They claim that if someone weighs the same as a duck, they must be made of wood and, therefore, a witch. Of course, this is pure nonsense, but it serves as a satirical criticism of the irrational and superstitious thinking that often accompanied accusations of witchcraft during historical periods.

It’s important to note that in reality, witchcraft is a complex and diverse practice, with different traditions and beliefs across cultures. It is not something that can be easily identified by a simple test or physical characteristic.

The Three Major Signs

However, if we were to play along with the Monty Python sketch, let’s explore the three major signs they suggest for identifying a witch:

  1. She turned me into a newt: According to the sketch, if a woman has the power to turn someone into a newt, she must be a witch. Of course, this is a purely fictional element, but it adds to the absurdity and comedic value of the scene.
  2. Burn her: The villagers suggest that if the accused woman burns, she must be a witch. This plays into the stereotype that witches are resistant to fire, a common belief during witch trials. Again, this is purely fictitious and not based on any real evidence.
  3. She looks like one: The last sign mentioned in the sketch is that if someone looks like a witch, they must be one. This is a prime example of the villagers’ flawed logic, as it demonstrates how subjective and biased appearances can be when it comes to accusations.

It’s essential to understand that these signs are not based on any factual evidence or logical reasoning. They are simply comedic devices used to highlight the absurdity of witch-hunting and the dangers of relying on stereotypes and superficial judgments.


In conclusion, determining if someone is a witch is not a matter of finding specific telltale signs or using the methods depicted in the Monty Python sketch. Witchcraft, as a real practice, is diverse and complex, with no one-size-fits-all approach to identification.

While the comedic portrayal of witch hunting in Monty Python’s sketch may provide laughs, it’s essential to remember that real accusations of witchcraft throughout history have led to the persecution and harm of innocent people. It is crucial to approach the topic with sensitivity, understanding, and a commitment to separating fact from fiction.

So, the next time someone asks you, “How do you know she’s a witch?” take a step back, examine your own beliefs and biases, and remember the importance of critical thinking and empathy.