How Do You Know She’s A Witch Monty Python

How To Articles

Have you ever watched Monty Python and the Holy Grail and wondered, “How do you know she’s a witch?” Well, my fellow Python enthusiasts, today I am delving deep into this perplexing question to unravel the mystery behind the witch identification process in this hilarious comedy classic.

First and foremost, let’s set the stage. In the scene I’m referring to, our brave knights of the Round Table encounter a village where accusations of witchcraft run rampant. A pompous knight, Sir Bedevere, takes it upon himself to educate the townsfolk on how to identify these alleged witches.

Now, it’s important to note that Monty Python’s portrayal of witch-hunting is a satirical commentary on the absurdity of such practices. The film cleverly mocks the irrationality of witch hunts that were prevalent during the medieval era.

The Witch Identification Test

According to Sir Bedevere’s reasoning, witches can be identified by their weight, their ability to float, and their affinity for wood. Yes, you heard that right – wood! If she weighs the same as a duck and can float in water, she must be made of wood and therefore, a witch. Makes perfect sense, doesn’t it?

Of course, this ludicrous test is intentionally farcical and highlights the nonsensical nature of witchcraft trials. It’s important to remember that Monty Python’s aim is to entertain and satirize, rather than provide accurate historical information.

Unpacking the Absurdity

Let’s dive deeper into the absurdity of this witch identification logic. The idea that someone could be made of wood simply because they float like a duck is comically irrational. It’s a prime example of how false assumptions and faulty reasoning can lead to disastrous consequences.

In the context of the film, this absurdity is intended to expose the inherent flaws in witch trials and the danger of jumping to conclusions based on superficial evidence. By presenting such a ridiculous test, Monty Python shines a light on the irrationality and injustice of real-life witch-hunts that caused immense suffering throughout history.

A Personal Touch

As a Monty Python fan myself, I can’t help but appreciate the brilliant wit and humor behind this scene. It’s a clever commentary on the dangers of blind belief and prejudice. The comedic genius of the Monty Python troupe lies in their ability to use laughter as a tool to challenge societal norms and question authority.

Watching this scene always reminds me of the importance of critical thinking and the dangers of blindly following the crowd. It serves as a timeless reminder to examine our own beliefs and not be swayed by baseless accusations or misguided hysteria.


Monty Python’s “How do you know she’s a witch?” scene is a comedic masterpiece that cleverly satirizes the irrationality of witch-hunting. While the witch identification test may be absurd and illogical, it serves as a powerful reminder of the devastating consequences that can arise from prejudice and blind faith.

So, next time you find yourself pondering the question of how to identify a witch, remember the words of Monty Python: “If she weighs the same as a duck… She’s made of wood. And therefore… A WITCH!”